Why does this sound awfully familar? 10 Zen V. Crook

8  2019-08-06 by DarxcideLB

"Michael Crook, a controversial public speaker, was at the center of a DMCA takedown lawsuit. Apparently, after a TV appearance on Fox, 10 Zen Monkeys posted a criticism of him online, which included a thumbnail picture. So, Crook sued for copyright infringement.

The judge put an end to the legal action, explaining that not only was a thumbnail image fair use, but since Fox made the show, Crook could not even claim ownership of intellectual property associated with the segment. The parties quickly settled and Crook agreed to a pair of unique conditions:

  1. Take courses on copyright law, so as to never again file a false DMCA takedown request; and
  2. Publish a public apology;
    http://www.dmlp.org/threats/crook-v-10-zen-monkeys
    All the internet lawyers are in agreement. I advise you to cease in violating the first amendment rights of this sub and other great original content providers.

u/doxxer100 I look forward to your public apology.

6 comments

Some further legal advice:

THE ULTIMATE FALSE DMCA CONSEQUENCE? PRISON!

Willing to risk the civil damages described above? Think the ROI is worth it? Think again. Since the DMCA has criminal provisions, and takedown notice senders must swear that their requests are valid “under penalty of perjury,” filing a false one can reap criminal repercussions.

Bottom line: Alleging copyright infringement, when it does not exist, is not a wise move."

http://www.aaronkellylaw.com/consequences-of-filing-a-false-dmca-takedown-request/

You're playing checkers in a game of chess, Joesph.

Straight from the Aaron Kelly Law website:

“Joe, a (fictional) copyright holder, discovers another party is using his protected works.

Joe sends a letter to either the website or hosting company on which the infringed content sits.”

Haha

Oh man, good ol' Mikey Crook, that sure takes me back. He was so much fun to fuck with.

Thing is, good old "Object Permanence Joe" things his statutory declarations disappear five minutes after he makes them.

They don't, though - they're all neatly logged and stored, waiting for a DA looking for an easy bust to find them.

He's easy pickins for whatever local politician wants to look tough on crime

I’d think he’d have one of the best personal injury lawyers a box of steaks could buy.