Anthony Cumia and SelfCuttingGirl (Updated)

318  2019-03-18 by wannabuyaghost

I've been adding to the original post over the last few months and will continue to do so. If you have anything relevant to contribute then post it here and I'll add it to the list.

This centers around the SelfCuttingGirl catfish story, in which a 40 year old man fooled Anthony, and many others, into believing he was a 14 year old girl. Read that post here. Also, keep in mind that this is who these people thought they were communicating with.

"The Hunter" is Jordan Hembrough and the other girl-friend mentioned is shelbys__tweets; who claims to have turned 18 in late 2016, which would have made her around 13 or 14 when all of this was going down. I find it hard to believe that this is a real person, but that doesn't matter. It's worth mentioning that this is one of the "real girls" Anthony brings up when discussing the reveal on the show. Anthony still follows this girl on twitter, btw, or at least he did before he was banned.

We'll start at the end and then double back to when Jordan Hembrough, a TV show host in his 40's, decided it was appropriate to contact what he believed to be a 14 year old girl, make inappropriate comments, take her on as a pseudo employee, and make even more inappropriate jokes that would make even Chip cringe (It's like an Army joke). Oof. You probably noticed a reference to Penn Jilette in there, too. Apart from Anthony and Jordan, Penn was one of the most publicly engaging celebrities.

Now here's the old O&A gang discussing the fact that they'd been had. The more I listen to this the more I notice how panicked everyone sounds. High-pitch Jimmy denies knowing anything about her while also claiming that he knew she was really a he all along, Opie kinda knows something, but not as much as everyone else, and Anthony tries to frame the conversation in a way that emphasizes how much of a creep this guy is for pretending to be an underage girl, despite the fact that he had been grooming "her" for well over a year.

Yeah, about that: Here's an old thread full of information. Linked threads: first and second. Here's Anthony denying that he'd ever been catfished in the first place & the thread. Remember ApologyGirl21? This is her. It's possible that this girl is one of the "real friends" that Ant was complaining about opening up to SelfCuttingGirl, too. Here's the thread where Ant deletes his denial. Here's Anthony claiming that he bought SelfCuttingGirl a macbook because he's a charitable fellow. Here's Ant's 17 year old girlfriend, ApologyGirl21, being used to lure in more strays and Ant offering SelfCuttingGirl room and board.

Here's a section of a blog post by Melissa Statten, one of Anthony's ex's, entitled: Trophy Wife aka My Life With A Shock Jock & the full version, which discusses her finding out that he had saved this 14 year old girl's Amazon wishlist "because she's a fan of the show and she's cute". Here's Anthony publicly thumbing his nose at his ex for getting upset that he's purchasing gifts for what he believed to be a 14 year old girl. Here's a bonus clip of Melissa Statten exposing Tranthony Cumio as a ladyboy lover and the thread. I should probably clarify why the Sue Lightning/tranny stuff is relevant...This is why.

The reason I haven't posted any direct communications between Anthony and this "girl" is because at some point during the whole hullabaloo of Ant admitting that he was catfished, then claiming that the catfished story never happened, him saying she was just a girl who the guys on the show retweeted, then claiming that he bought her things because he's a charitable guy, and even going so far as to pretend that SelfCuttingGirl was his niece at one point...he decided to wipe his entire twitter account the same way he wiped his Vine account. Bonus: His reaction to the Vine likes. The only problem with wiping your account clean is that all of the @ mentions are still there. There are some speculative things. I'm not sure what to make of that. I don't know who that message was sent to, but there's enough left over to paint a picture of what was really going on. Plus, you'd be a fool to not take the man at his word.

A few more instances:

  • Anthony brings child porn to play on the show.

  • Anthony creeps out some teenage girls by taking pictures of them in a restaurant. Archived photo and Tweets.

  • Here his taking a creepshot of a girl who couldn't have been more than 8 years old.

  • Another round of 'How young would you go' where Anthony "jokes" about having sex with 9 year olds. He later changes his answer to 15.

  • There's his friendship with Kurt Love, the sex offender who was sent to prison for sodomizing a 12 year old.

  • Here's Anthony drooling over Bobo's underage sister and a thread where former producer for O&A, Danny (/u/TheBlueAwning), claims that convicted pedophile, Kurt Love aka Jeffery Hollander, brought Bobo's then 16 year old sister and a friend over to Anthony's house for a pool party. Link and archive link of the thread where he delivers with the photo that corroborates his story. Here's Anthony's response to Danny (1hr35mins) and Danny's response to the response, in which Danny alleges that Anthony digitally penetrated a 14 year old girl in his home theater room. Archive link.

  • Anthony drooling over the 13 year old cash me outside girl. Taken from TACS 537 1:12:00. He filed a copyright claim on the latter for obvious reasons, but the thread is still up. Edit: A little snippet of the kinds of things he was saying.

  • In 2006 Ant did an impression of a guy defending his own pedophilia, he later went on to repeat those words but in defense of himself.

  • He referred to Roman Polanski as a hero for anally raping a 13 year old girl.

  • E-Rock and Opie lied to Olympic gymnast Mikayla Mirony, then 17, for a disturbing bit on the show. What makes this even more egregious on their part is that it took place after Anthony had caused a Twitter shit storm by Tweeting about breaking Mikayla's hymen. Some of the Tweets, which were all sent before this bit, are saved in this article.

  • On August 14, 2018 it was discovered that former O&A producer, Erik Nagel, made a comment in a thread titled "What should have stayed in Vegas, but didn't?" on /r/AskReddit about a former co-worker. He wrote, "An ex co-worker of mine got blackout drunk and wouldn't stop trying to pick up this young teen in front of her family. Her father almost fought him, but an off-duty police officer stepped in and convinced the guy to get upstairs and go to bed." Within a couple of hours of this admission being posted to /r/opieandanthony Erik wiped his account history and created two new posts in an attempt to make it look like the account was owned by someone else. There have been rumors circulating that Erik would be joining Anthony's podcast network in some capacity prior to this happening, which would explain his panic.

  • This is a Periscope video taken by his ex, Dani Brand (Golightly), in which she says that the only reason Anthony bought a drone was to look at middle school girls. In the video he can be seen hovering the drone over the local middle school and junior high school.

  • Here's Anthony saying that he would only watch ICarly to jerk off. Jimmy seriously asks what's wrong with him. There's no joke there.

  • Another instance of him commenting on how hot he finds a teenage girl.

  • In this clip Anthony insinuates that if he had become a carnival worker he would have statutory rape charges all across America for sleeping with 14 year olds.

  • There's the whole 'Ant goes to prom' bit, too. Part 1 and Part 2.

  • Here's a clip of him saying that a 14 year old prostitute on Maury is "completely, legitimately fuckable".

  • Bill Burr says that Anthony has The Neverland Ranch for someone who doesn't molest kids and Anthony replies with, "...Little do you know."

  • Here he is admitting to finding the sexual abuse of women arousing. Here he is taking photos of a passed out girl and posting them to Twitter.

  • Here he is flat out admitting that he slept with a 14 year old when he was 21...or 18? Either way, it's illegal.

  • This is possibly a reference to the same girl. This time he says that he was dating a 15 year old when he was 19 years old.

SelfCuttingGirl's ask.fm page and a few answers. The questions are anonymous, obviously, but I feel this also helps to paint a fuller picture of the relationship between Cumia and what he thought was a 14 year old girl.

118 comments

This is how and why Anthony's faggot ass cant SUE us unless hes talking about sucking off a tranny before buying him tits

doing the lord's work, bravo.

Because you were there... STFU. Zero credibility shitcunt.

The majority of the things in this post are literally clips of Anthony and archives of his social media posts. How is that not credible?

Sup Ant/Joe!

Lick my nuts you ghoulish looking child rapist... or perhaps the cow looking ass child spit drinker. Either way this is probably a Cumia

This has to be Joe. Less than 30 day old account. The first post he makes, he runs crying to HateSubsInAction about us.. He refers to Joe as “the big lug” while asking what Joe ever did wrong. No one likes Joe except Joe. And I absolutely believe Joe would spell intellectual that way.

It's fucking hilarious. Joe was sitting there, trying to come up with a sympathetic Reddit name:

"Ah, I'll call myself an 'intellectual homosexual', the SJWs will love that.'"

Then his very first post is an attempt to get the sub shut down.

Even the dopes trying to get T_D shut down are more subtle than THAT.

Forget the lack of subtlety, just the sheer unimaginativeness of it is telling (because it's so jaw-droppingly dumb). He really thought he concocted a way to use our strategies against us. And ... that ... was the result.

And yeah, it's hilariously unsubtle, but also just flat out lazy that he figured "if I just put homosexual in my name, that will convey the message 100%!" He wouldn't even know where to begin a convincing campaign that might garner actual sympathy.

Joseph Cumia. Potato Peeler til the end of time. "Peels bad, go dat pot. Big white balls good, go dat pot.

He's just such a larping weirdo. Two week ago he pretends to be a teenager, now he's A Noted Gay Man In The Intellectual Community.

It would be delightful if Joe catfished Ant at some point.

Yo, bovine brain.

Zero credibility shitcunt.

Does Anthony know that's what you call him?

Don't you feel even a little bit sickened by having to bend over backwards and ignore literal facts to defend a pedophile? Is it really worth the pittance you get from this? I know that you Cumio Bros. lack the ability to feel shame but do you also lack any sort of ability to use basic judgment?

All this trouble and headache and hassle to defend a pedophile. For what? Because he has a pool and a karaoke machine? Your entire bloodline needs to be put down. You're diseased.

Hi Joe. Enjoy the buttfucking at the Big Apple Ranch shitbag.

Wow.... Gonna have to save this one for a total listen and read next weekend... This is an amazing amount of things to go thru although I have probably heard 80% of it already... Thank you!

I remember when this show was just a fun stupid thing that I listened to in the afternoon after work in new york. SHEEESH!

Ain't it fun?

Just a container of coffee and an AM/FM radio, I'm good.

Thank you Regular Moe

Nice repost, stupid. But anyways this should be stickied and be the first result when you Google Anthony.

This must be stickied. Mods, please. This is extremely important information and it must be shared and accessible for future reference.

To be fair to Penn Jillette, I don't think anything shady was going on there with him. He used to reply to pretty much everyone who wrote to him on Twitter. There was a lot of crossover with O&A fans.

It's possible. Shit gets muddied and everything must be taken with a grain of salt. This ladies Facebook post was pretty interesting, though.

Hey, there's something about the link that's not letting me approve the post. Edit it and use Tinyurl or something.

That work? The site I linked to might be banned after the events from this past week.

im assuming it is banned now.

Nope. Sorry.

This is way past getting out of hand.

Pin this. Fuck your gay faggot weekly FFA

Somehow....some way....we NEED those “Gisele” texts from Dani. She’s thicc and happy now, so I don’t want to drag her back into this nonsense. We just need the texts (screenshot or otherwise) from the source; she can go back to her regular LA life, and we can destroy the Cumias.

link me to thicc dani

I somehow missed this. What are the "Gisele texts"?

Is this the chick whose dad worked for Clinton?

That's apologygirl. She's the one in the Christmas picture. SelfCuttingGirl is the catfish

Yup. Whoever was hosting that X-Mas pic deleted it, but the link has been fixed. I forget whose page the pic of Whoo Kid, E-Rock, and The Toy Hunter was on, but they deleted that as well. Fixed that, too.

Thank you sir

”Anthony, you should be put to sleep.” - Patrice O’neal

"You piece of trash". Human garbage

The only one brave enough to say this to the pedo fag

i believe patrice actually left the show after hearing ant say that he would fuck a 13 year old

The Anthony Cumia Show has been reduced to popeye and looney tunes impressions from Anthony. Get those subscriptions folks!

he did. he walked out and ant went ha ha ho le shit patrice is leaving.

Just by listening the tone of Opie you know this is true, and everyone knew about it.

just read the stetten letter.. it has to suck being half famous, then the woman you dated are fucking writing blogs about all the shit you did during the relationship and talk about it on podcasts.. just trying to use that shit for publicity.. fucking rats are everywhere

It probably sucks less than having a sickly-looking pedophile cheat on you with something resembling a young child and then, even though he's the one who ruined the relationship, goes on his national radio show to tell the world about your fecal incontinence for no real reason.

I don't care that she cyber stalked Nana to discover his tranny breast purchases, and that she later had a hipster funeral in a broken down bus. She's a good egg.

His personal assistant who also happens to be a cop

he liked to do turned into him drinking every night watching awful reality TV shows and complaining about liberals

his life was him and his show and his guns

There's no proof she's talking about Anthony, though. She could be talking about Scott Ferrall.

Absolutely disgusting. Anyone who still supports Anthony is a piece of shit and probably also a pedophile as well.

No doubt , sadly i thought he was funny at 1 time but now i wanna cave his fuckin skull in for sexually abusing children

Would it have been that hard to type "one"?

It was funny when I thought it was a joke. I’m not above saying that I’ve accidentally found an underage girl attractive, hanging out with friends and seeing a girl and saying something about her, only for someone to say “shes like 16 dude” and quickly begging for forgiveness from god, any god. But there’s a difference between that and actively seeking out 13-16 year old chicks like Ant does, especially when you’re a millionaire and can afford to fuck of age women, no matter how ghoulish you are in appearance.

But back in the day I thought it was all jokes for the radio. “Oh Ant, ya old kid fucker”...Going back to and listening to those old clips now gives me the chills man. He’s a ghoul, no doubt.

has this been printed out and mailed to him yet?

Thank you for your autism

Haha he really is a sick fuck creep

It's amazing people just glossed over it for so long. Part of the reason was that the 'Olson twins clock' sounded so much like nothing more than a shock radio bit. And they had another - well, not really a bit or running gag, but whatever. Where they would always be saying "any time the word TEEEEEN is in something, it can't get better". Usually they were referencing porn (legit porn), so you're like, yeah I guess, what's wrong with that? Legal 18 and 19 year old women .... ok if that's your thing. 18, 19, 22, 25, they pretty much all look the same, right?

Not to Anthony apparently. Or at least, it was clearly more than a matter of the physical with him.

I forgot about the Olson Twins shit. Here's an original Brother Joe song he wrote when they were underage. Here's a bit about them called "Ant's in my Pants".

Has Sam ever addressed the catfish any further than what was discussed on air? Listening to that again and he seems to be the most informed of anyone. Sam was the one who Hembrough called and told about it and then Sam was the one who informed Ant. Not to mention Hembrough was a guest on the after show a week or two before he even found out. He comes in at the 5 minute mark.

Dude sam is the most calculating and cunning person. The prodegy of Opie. He probably knew every deatail of that story, and would have used it if Ant didnt get fired to get that spot. > https://www.reddit.com/r/opieandanthony/comments/agrpo8/a_seventh_documentary_accusing_anthony_cumia_of/

If by calculating and cunning and you mean disingenuous and weaselly.

Nice spelling of progeny, stupid.

It's important to keep all of this in mind when Ant calls us losers.

Anthony Cumia is a piece of shit

Anthony Cumia is a pedophile

"I heard that this one guy..."

Jeez who could Anthony be referring to

THANK YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE

Everyone here was defending this creepy behaviour, you're only mad because you feel like he's turned on you. Fucking weirdos.

Imagine being this person

Well, that's embarrassing

You should send this to buzzfeed or other such gay sites

[removed]

As if they will put the resources on destroying some no name black podcaster

It's fun to see all the new people amazed by this. Theres no way this should ever be forgotten.

Could you imagine what would happen if the authorities got wind of this?

What a hideous person. Inside and out.

Here he is drooling over the now 15 year old cash me ousside girl again fairly recently https://www.reddit.com/r/opieandanthony/comments/agrpo8/a_seventh_documentary_accusing_anthony_cumia_of/

Anthony's a pretty warped and twisted guy who's openly said some pretty dark and fucked-up shit on the radio. A grown man practically moaning in lust over iCarly is not normal.

Even more abnormal is how little effort he puts into hiding it. The Patrice 13 clip is really just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to that. In his mind everyone thinks like him, and he's society's victim in that he can't be free to talk about it, but maybe tomorrow or next week they'll all finally come out and simultaneously admit to it. Maybe change a few of those pesky laws.

I can't believe nobody remembers when he discovered "Toddlers & Tiaras". You know he watched it because of how crazy the moms were on the show. Sure Ant, sure.

I ain't reading all that shit.

I've been trying to find this for a while but there was definitely an O&A show where Ant keeps taking about his well thought out plan to wipe and destroy his hard drive all where the cops try to get it

Might explain why he used a shotgun in his home on a computer.

HA HA HA Holy shit

Hole-leeeeeeeee-shit

Not defending Ant here, but what is the proof that the girl in the pic isnt his niece?

Nana doesn't have a niece.

I

HATE Anthony Cumia

We're gonna need /u/BeigeFrequency to make an addendum to the Demented World series featuring all this updated information

In one of the early shows Gavin did on Compound he brought these southern girls in to ostensibly get Rat laid. They're all in the pool together by the end and Dani pokes her head out of the house to say hello. I'm not subbed anymore so I'm not 100 percent sure but when I saw it I thought to myself she was roleplaying a child. Who knows maybe it was just her own craziness but I remember thinking there's something very odd going on at the Cumia residence.

Didn't one of the southern girls ask if she was Ant's daughter?

there's something very odd going on at the Cumia residence.

It's hard to argue against that. Here's my take on it.

Ant was absolutely attracted to her because of her featureless, prepubescent body and little girl voice. She also seems incredibly immature and childish. I'm not sure if she played the voice thing up for his sake or not (my guess is not considering her father's weird as fuck voice). But it's exactly like how Sue said Ant was probably attracted to her because she looks like a 13 year old girl.

Have you ever seen any of Dani's periscopes at Ant's house (besides the famous ones)? It looks like hell. She could not be more obnoxious and her voice is incredibly grating. Ant seems like he detests her presence in every one of them. But he kept her around and put up with all of that shit every day just so that he could occasionally fuck something resembling a little girl.

Whatever your opinion on Missy's looks/personality is, she's much more pleasant than Dani. But Ant ended that relationship for Dani and only started fucking Missy again after Dani's periscopes. She was the backup plan but Dani is the ideal "woman" to him.

There is really nothing new going on in the O&A universe huh, oh well was fun while it lasted. Keep up the autism my friend! It’s all we have left.

Seriously, how much do you get paid to research all this? You have to be in your 30s or older to know this much about the show. You definitely do not get laid.

You can donate to my patreon page at patreon.com/icopyandpasteshitotherpeoplepost.

That really is the mantra of this sub. Copy/paste, repeat.

NEVVEER!!!#

Holy autism

I wonder how many times Joe and Ant have fucked over the years.

A googol.

It's kind of cut and dry right? He's a pretty disgusting individual.

I'm Irish. I got into the show 10 years ago via Ron and fez. The very first thing my friend (who had gotten me into the shows) said to me about them was: Ants the funny one......but he's a racist and total piece of shit.

Funny how id kind of forgotten/ignored it for so long.

Two conclusions can be drawn from this.

  1. You have autism.
  2. Anthony Cumia is a pedophile.

firstly, youre a faggot. knowing you wasted your life on this nonsense brings me joy.

and the term is hebephilia but i think anthony has ephebophilia, as do most heterosexual adult men.

He's a hebephile at the very least. The type of girls who are on that Maury show he was frothing over are in early adolescence and these are the girls he's willing to publicly express his lust for.

TL;DR Anth might not be a nice person

Man, I loved Anthony Cumia. I thought he was really funny and have enjoyed countless hours of O&A. It really appears that he's a sick old man, and probably a dangerous one, according to these autistic threads. Good job!

key word: "appears".

can someone send in all of this evidence to the FBI so they can start their own investigation?

Hoooly shit

As messed up as Ant is, he could've had a lot of women who were legal age and lived what might be considered an enviable life. Honestly I hate Ant, not just for what he's become, but because he used to be a funny guy who could roll with jokes and lived what seemed to be an interesting life and turned into the grotesque troll he is today. Fuck...

Fuck sakes there's "separating the art from the artist" but I don't think I can even listen to the old bits anymore

I have recollections of him discussing his desire to be with the, what appears to be a teenage, surfing girl from a United Healthcare commercial. https://youtu.be/-8iKRozB2uQ

Fucking Jimmy is the most unconvincing, creepy piece of shit on the planet. "Of course I knew it was a guy.....how'd you know?" Worst liar I ever heard or seen.

You are fake news.

Now back to the glory hole fella.

[removed]

Welcome to reddit sockcucka! New users are able to submit posts after 5 days. If you think your post is a fair contribution to the subreddit, message the moderators for a faster approval.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

Creeping on Steve Erwin's 14 year old daughter

You guys high five each other for trolling and possing off one person. With one post, /u/space_edge got all you autists triggered and throwing a fit.

Fascinating to go back and see but really disturbing he's an ill thing

That work? The site I linked to might be banned after the events from this past week.

Forget the lack of subtlety, just the sheer unimaginativeness of it is telling (because it's so jaw-droppingly dumb). He really thought he concocted a way to use our strategies against us. And ... that ... was the result.

And yeah, it's hilariously unsubtle, but also just flat out lazy that he figured "if I just put homosexual in my name, that will convey the message 100%!" He wouldn't even know where to begin a convincing campaign that might garner actual sympathy.

Joseph Cumia. Potato Peeler til the end of time. "Peels bad, go dat pot. Big white balls good, go dat pot.