Poor Jimmy can't catch a break; The Comedian (Feb 3) is at 31% on RottenTomatoes

27  2017-01-29 by Doc_McCoy79

I remember them playing a clip of this on Jimmy Fallon or something a while back, and it was so bad. They couldn't even fit a funny part in the 2:30 clip they were trying to promote. I wish De Niro would just do the Irishman, and die the minute they call picture wrap.

Hats off to James for being in a movie with De Niro (if he made the final cut), but it's too bad this looks like an instantly forgettable piece of shit. Jeff Ross wrote it too; I wonder if it sucked or if the studio took it and mangled his script. Who knows. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/the_comedian_2017

53 comments

He said his part is even smaller than it was in Spiderman.

Did he really? Jesus. I thought he had like a couple of scenes with him.

The movie looks like garbage and I'm not gonna watch it, but at least De Niro dropped his name on Fallon (around 1:48). And he probably got another photo for his wall of celebrity pics.

Did it sound like he was about to say "Lil Jimmy" to anyone else?

He might have been doing "self deprivation jimmy".

De Niro will never be funny.

The only thing I thought he was funny in was Meet The Parents, and Analyze This. Then they drag that "good for one movie" premise out into 2 & 3 installments and it's like "fucking hell..."

Midnight Run is funny, but he's playing an asshole, it's not like 'pure comedy.' He's horrible casting to try to play an actual comedian, I guess he loves stand up & funny people so he wanted to do it. Bad move, Bobby.

The only thing I thought he was funny in was Meet The Parents, and Analyze This

Analyze This/That were embarrassments.

Meh. Analyze This is mediocre, but it definitely works and there are jokes that do land.

Billy Crystal lol

Analyze This is pretty funny. It's not The Naked Gun but it's entertaining and has a good handful of genuinely funny moments. Plus De Niro is present AF in that movie, he doesn't play the character 'funny,' which is what made Midnight Run so good. It might not hold up as good 17 years later but at the time it was pretty solid.

Analyze That, to quote the mafia parlance, "forget about it!" LOLLL!!!!! (ties noose around neck)

Stop comparing Midnight Run to that Billy Crystal faggotry.

Make me.

I bet you liked City Slickers also

City Slickers rules.

City Slickers was terrible. Billy Crystal or not.

Throw Mama was great, can't argue with that one.

"The unsalted peanuts make me SHOKE..."

"Owen loves his Mama"

Ever seen Raging Bull? He's fawkin hilarious.

A horse a horse my kingdom for a horse.... I havent picked a winner in 8 months.

De Niro is unintentionally hilarious. Louie CK talked about it on O&A but GoodFella's has a lot of funny lines from him. Joe Pesci as well, but he's hilarious off camera too.

Joe Pesci as well, but he's hilarious off camera too.

well wasn't he an actual comedian? of course he was hilarious, Tommy is basically the comic relief character. Also Marty was known for giving comedians roles because they could improvise and give better reads on meaningless dialogue.

Louie CK talked about it on O&A

was this before or after he talked about big black dicks?

Then I am a fool, and you should ignore me. I didn't know Pesci was a comedian.

I don't think he was always meant to be comic relief, even the scenes where he's meant to be taken seriously are hilarious is what I'm saying. Like him saying, "Hey, I'm a good shot" after killing that kid was very funny.

Are you suggesting that Louie CK talks about BBC's on O&A? That doesn't sound like him.

That doesn't sound like him.

yes it does, Louie CK only talks about two things, little white dicks and big black dicks

He was pretty funny in Cape Fear.

deniro "im a comedian"

(Breathes out his nose)

(looks side to side)

Having seen the trailer, I'm honestly surprised it's that high

It could get lower once more reviews come in. De Niro fucking stinks.

Jim only did it so he could get the picture.

In this case fair enough.

does de niro owe money?

Seems like it. Did you see The Intern? Holy shit. It was so embarrassing. Even the dumb broad that dragged me to see it hated it and we left like 50 minutes in. Mercifully.

I didn't see the Intern, but I'm guessing that De Niro and Hathaways characters were like oil and water at first, nothing but conflict, but then there's a montage scene where they get on the same page to accomplish a goal, and by the end they've taught each other some valuable lessons. Then they fuck.

Actually no. There was almost 0 conflict. She doesn't want him as an intern but gets to know him better but forgot she had someone transfer him. Literally the next scene is her talking to him at a coffee shop and asking him to come back on as her intern.

Her husband is cheating on her because she's never home but she knows and they decide to work things out.

The only source of conflict in the movie is the VCs want her to pick a CEO but she decides not to and then the movie ends.

It's one of the most meaningless pieces of filler feelgood shit I've ever seen.

It's fucking soulless. It's a soulless, overlit piece of garbage. WHY IS EVERY LIGHT IN EVERY ROOM ON FOR THE ENTIRE MOVIE. That husband was incomprehensibly bad casting and they had zero screen chemistry. You're right, there's virtually no conflict. It's a terrible movie on almost every conceivable level. It's like a Hallmark Channel movie, but with De Niro instead of Steve Guttenberg. They market it as a chick flick and something to appeal to the older demo, once you pay for your ticket or the rental, it's nothing but shit. They don't care because they already got your fucking money.

How about that horrendous musical montage on the plane when they're flying to LA, and De Niro's like "how about we forget about work and just have fun, and they're having apparently spirited & meaningful conversation? And at one point she whispers a secret in De Niro's ear, and he opens his eyes wide and puts his hands over his mouth. The dummy I was with looked at me and goes "Ok, let's go." Like we couldn't take another second of this dreck. (God she had great tits.)

Your mom is a cunt for making you see it.

Obviously the restaurant is failing.

doesn't he own part of Nobu? i tend to think he just loves acting in movies and doesn't care about his legacy so he takes whatever is offered because he doesn't want to stay home and sit on his ass.

He owns part of El Compadre on Sunset in LA across from Guitar Center too, I guess. He's in there a lot, I just missed him in there one night and I wanted to fucking cry. (He's still a goddamn legend) He owns a shit ton of real estate and a bunch of restaurants.

Yea I once read an article about how much his places in NY & LA cost. & according to google he has 6 kids and a couple of ex wives. Because he makes shit. Atleast when you look at Pacino's shitty movies there usually seems to be an attempt to make a good movie. But Deniro will do anything

Jack & Jill being the exception to that, of course.

Practically every classic film he ever made, he made (relatively speaking) fuck all money. It's a bit corny, but he really did "do it for the art" for 15-20 years. A few kids and some bad investments later and he started doing shit like Rocky and Bullwinkle. Read a biography about him a few years back. Apparently around the mid 90s he decided to focus more on pay cheques than "passion projects".

Ive read two De Niro biographies. It started way before that, he started doing every script that came across the table in the mid 80s onward, like We're No Angels with Sean Penn. It seemed like either he picked better scripts then or maybe people were just better writers, because his ratio of crap to decent flicks was a lot better. But as the years went on...god almighty. No fucking shame.

I heard Leslie Mann is fabulous in it. I might go see it just for her.

She is amazing. She totally doesn't just get roles because of her husband.

The characters she portrays are varied and deep.

Leslie Mann is in it? Didn't know Judd Apatow was directing.

Tsss I guess Leslie Mann is the only Mann in the relationship or sumpthin. Wordplay yuma

Jim stinks at acting. He doesn't deserve a break.

'While they establish a father-daughter rapport, there’s also something creepily romantic to their relationship and the push-pull between the pair becomes the film’s emotional through-line."

Oh, Uncle Paul

I wonder if it sucked or if the studio took it and mangled his script. Who knows.

Comedians write terrible fucking scripts. They treat characters as mouthpieces to wedge in lines and spell out the thematic points they're trying to communicate. I guarantee that DeNiro's character spends time explicitly talking out how old he feels, his regrets, his new plan of action, his disappointmemt when that plan fails and the lessons he's learned when everything wraps up.

yep spot on.

the fact that DeNiro is basically playing an old version of Jeff Ross doesn't help either

jeff "the insult comic" ross? how could he not write a compelling rich narrative

Ross's stand up is terrible. He's really a niche guy, like all his eggs are in one basket funny-wise: he's a cosmically gifted roast comic. Other than that he honestly doesn't have much going for him. I've seen him do stand up 3x at the Store, one was so bad he just started reading texts and stuff off his phone, he didn't even have a 15 minutes together.

He's a douche too, he's just a grouchy old jew that's nice to young gal comics he wants to fuck. I mean most comics are "that," but at least they try to hide it on some level.

Movies about stand-up never, ever work. The past is littered with failures, including a semi-recent one that also featured Mrs. Crapatow (Funny People).

I know Im in the extreme minority but I loved Funny People. It's my favorite thing he ever did. I want Yo, Teach! to be a show more than I want to breathe.

I didn't see the Intern, but I'm guessing that De Niro and Hathaways characters were like oil and water at first, nothing but conflict, but then there's a montage scene where they get on the same page to accomplish a goal, and by the end they've taught each other some valuable lessons. Then they fuck.

Your mom is a cunt for making you see it.

Jack & Jill being the exception to that, of course.

Ross's stand up is terrible. He's really a niche guy, like all his eggs are in one basket funny-wise: he's a cosmically gifted roast comic. Other than that he honestly doesn't have much going for him. I've seen him do stand up 3x at the Store, one was so bad he just started reading texts and stuff off his phone, he didn't even have a 15 minutes together.

He's a douche too, he's just a grouchy old jew that's nice to young gal comics he wants to fuck. I mean most comics are "that," but at least they try to hide it on some level.