Are Jimmys books worth reading?

12  2015-06-09 by JimmysLostFat

36 comments

If you like Jim's standup but hate watching him blink, yes.

If you like books, no.

Happy Endings / Tales of a Meaty Breasted Zilch is the quintessential young Norton collection of douche chilling stories. You get to hear all of his stories, and some he doesn't talk much about on the radio in that one pretty much. I give I Hate Your Guts a miss.

I especially liked when he filled the last half his last book with just lists, such as "People I'd like to see killed in a car accident on a family member's wedding day" etc. Who doesn't love a good list?

you can kill at least an hour a day with a good list.

That just sounds like Buzzfeed type listicle filler. Authors do that to fill up pages because there's not enough solid content.

We could've helped him write a few.

  1. You
  2. Me

Did he give explanations or just list people's names?

I honestly don't remember. I think some of them had short one or two sentence blurbs after them but nothing that would be a good excuse of "this isn't anything more than a list."

Happy Endings was good.

Don't think we got a lot of readers in here.
Books no work good in my head.

NO!

If you want the audiobook (read by him, foreword by Colin iirc) you can get it here

https://mega.co.nz/#F!5lYigZiB!e8LJ3UVgshOwb8nX901ejA

When I wore headphones at work all day, the audio books were good entertainment.

Yeah, they're not bad by any means. My favorite part was when he talks about how much of a faggot he was in rehab, and how he "accidentally" left a poem about his friends (Jack Daniels, etc) out in the open so everyone could read.

I cringe heavily at that part every time. I wish he never told it. However, the story he wrote for his then girlfriend was great.

Can't speak for I Hats Your Guts, but I tread Tales of a Meaty Breasted Zilch and loved it

I Hate your Guts was better IMO, he kinda stuck to 1 subject he hated and broke it down for its own chapter. Better written too.

Edgar?

IDK why someone would read an Opie biography tho

They're alright. Exactly what you would expect from him. A few laughs. If yore looking for something more substantial to make it worth your time and money look elsewhere

Happy Endings was good. The other one was annoying. Full of over the top name-calling trying to be funny. It failed.

Yes, both of his books are better than any stand up he's done.

You'll laugh out loud reading them.

I love in Happy Endings when he describes the Indian couple sitting behind him as smelling like"spicy logs of shit".

I was reading his blog while they were off the air between 2002-2004. I think he used quite a bit of those stories in his first book, though I never read the first book. The stories gave me a decent enough laugh. Nothing hysterical......but I am always amused with his creepy stories.

I loved both but I am biased because I think he is a very funny guy.

I enjoyed them. I just finally finished I hate your guts which is mostly topics he has talked about already. The first one had more unknown stories if I remember correctly

Yes especially the first one

I'm a fan of Jimmy, and I'd say his books are a better example of his comedy than his specials are.

I like them both. They're pretty hilarious. Last year on my birthday, I went to Half Price Books to sell a bunch of shit for store credit, and after I grabbed a b few new things, I checked humor and got Happy Endings for three bucks, since I had I Hate Your Guts at home. I opened it in the car to see that it was signed. That was awesome.

Kinda meh.

Poor Mans Artie Lange books

No, they're awful.

The jokes in his books are as ham-handed as the jokes in his standup.

He is not a very talented writer. He conveys funny material, yet his writing is worse than his concepts are funny.

In the end, Jim is not an academic. He is an incredibly talented comedian who possesses an admirable wit, a wit most of us don't have. But he's not a writer. Maybe he will be as he continues to seek improvement. But those books are not worth the money.

Both are good/hilarious reads, but his first book was the better of the two.