Opie goes hard on heavy with the victim card, changes his story entirely and denies/obfuscates the things he said before. He tries to get Anthony in the corner by eating up time with an irrelevant and dumb point.  

Anthony throws jabs, but isn't nearly as vitriolic as his buzzed tweets. He doesn't quite go for the throat because jimmy is there.  

Jimmy sits in the corner and says nothing, when it's brought up he acts pious about sitting it out because he has nothing to do with it. He may try to lighten it up a bit (which will obviously hurt anthony).  

Outcome- everyone still hates opie, they think anthony went too hard/was soft, roll their eyes about jimmy.  

The 'good radio' outcome- opie admits he was lying the whole time and says something to the effect of always hating anthony, he fires jimmy the jokeman, hires an agreeable black woman named 'Sparrow' and changes the show name to 'Gregshells in the morning- Fun Radio Served Sunny Side Up'.   Oh and Sam Roberts pulls a Chris Benoit the day after the fight and Erock has a heart attack during the last O+J show of the year. Troy goes through a sex change and starts dating Joe Derosa and Travis' mom (ironically a raving anti-semite) becomes Anthony's co star. I don't think the last part will ever happen though.