Ant's Rogan podcast appearance removed from youtube (probably by Brother Joe)

18  2014-10-13 by [deleted]

Apparently removed by SBS Shameful Brother Services? You decide.

HERE is the show if you haven't heard it yet

38 comments

Supposedly, some guy we'll call "Christopher Schmidt", for the sake of respect and privacy, filed a copyright claim to have the entire JRE podcast featuring Ant pulled because it featured 1 min of his video.

The worst part is, rumor has it that folks are using this persons' YouTube channel (https://www.youtube.com/user/crschmidt/featured) and also his personal site, (http://crschmidt.net/), to lash out and vent their frustration over this upstanding gentleman's decision.

Absolutely appalling he would be harassed for allegedly filing a copyright claim pulling an entire JRE episode featuring Ant... Shame on you people.

What a shithead. Rogan knows the risks though, he's mentioned this subject (JRE pulled from Youtube for stuff they played during broadcast) many times on his podcast.

Doesn't Fair Use apply as long as they're providing commentary on it?

That concept is almost nonexistent on YouTube anymore.

I just read a comment of his where he mentions it's not his fault as he is getting shit on by same content ID nuisance.

I was literally in the middle of watching it and it got taken down.

looks like the gook equivalent of viral spiral, maybe they infringed on playing a video.

bosintang is tasty treat if you are what you eat with surplus virility can accomplish feat, gaegogi always best meat. JUCHE.

This is the second time I've seen this "viral spiral" thing pop up? Is this really a thing where Jimmy is paid to promote bullshit like the Bee-man and the mexican dude who by pretending he accidentally stumbled on these videos and bringing them up on air? Cause that's so douchey

SACRILEGE! OPIE is the douchebag you speak of, NOT Jimmy. Opie was recruited by a big company in England, if you really want to know. They're in partnership with HBO on a project that Opie can't give the details on since it's in pre-production. They're also collaborating on an MTV special which uses Opie's EXCLUSIVE video of what appears to be Banksy. YES! BANKSY!

Gotcha! I was just looking for information as I've heard the viral spiral thing mentioned here a few times but never on air and was curious if Jimmy's quirky little youtube video discoveries were stealth advertising for some bullshit ring of bad youtube videos

It's pretty cringy if you ask me

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=01zXo6g7l-o

God you can just tell jim is trying to dig opie out of a hole. He knows that opie is just embarrassing himself and Jim is trying to overtake opie with british chip.

jim finds himself in that position pretty frequently. lol

Hey guys, have any of you listened to the Joseph Cumia Show? This guy is really good. He will have a gig on SiriusXM in 6 months, mark my words.

Ok, thats a lie. It's god awful.

Fucking Koreans..... Wait what.... Did they show any videos or anything Korean that I'm not aware of?

https://www.youtube.com/user/SBSContentsHubs/feed

Are you sure it's that one?

SBS Broadcasting Group, originally Scandinavian, now also operating in various other European countries
Special Broadcasting Service, an Australian multilingual and multicultural radio and television service
Seoul Broadcasting System, a South Korean television network
Shizuoka Broadcasting System, a Japanese radio and TV broadcasting station in Shizuoka Prefecture
Spanish Broadcasting System, a United States radio and TV operator

It's down on rogans podcast site too, fucking lame ass shit

You can still watch it on his ustream channel.

http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/53798450

Maybe because Brian showed the uncensored meatball sandwich hooker for a brief second before putting up the edited one? I watched it this morning and when that part aired I figured it wouldn't be up much longer. It's still up on Vimeo though.

Do the same rules apply to TACS?

The nice things about TACS in this regard are that it isn't served from Youtube and that nearly everything is behind the subscriber curtain. Anthony's content isn't being continually scanned by an automated system looking for "infringement", so it'd take an actual person to notice a potential issue and send a DMCA takedown letter.

Why would he have taken it down?

on today's TACS, Anthony (well, Keith really) confirmed the video of the hawk taking down the drone was under trademark, or copyright protection, and needs to be edited out of the episode of JRE.

Cause he's jam....

I just downloaded the podcast from pocketcasts on android. What happened? Why is it being taking down?

Just announced on Ant's show that the goober who posted the hawk video filed a copywrite claim, so they had to take the video down and edit that part out.

Correction: The guy who made the video didn't send a takedown notice. He's pissed about it too and defending himself all over twitter.

Prep the torches, sharpen the pointy pitchforks.... Ready the hoards

Says it was "the user" who removed the video.

MORE

HAMSTERS

FOR

THE

CAGE

Why would joseph cumia remove it?

Why wouldn't he?

I see no motivation behind it other than just to spite his brother. Which I see no reason for.

It's back up.

Whether it is a third party claim or Youtube's content ID system, it seems like it would fall under fair use and is not protected.

Fair use is a very broad category. If you're using it for parody, education, criticism etc. - all of that falls under fair use. Having items be unprotected is essential to the spread and improvement of knowledge/ideas.

Of course JRE or TACS is parody/criticism. They are similar to Tosh.0 - and able to use the clips.

While one could argue that JRE and TACS use the clips to profit, the use is super limited and would fall under the scope of fair use. Kimmel, Fallon, Tosh etc. all do the same, with no fear of copyright claims.

I really hate the arbitrary copyright claims that YT and other sites allow to exist without any thought of fair use. It's lazy and intellectually dishonest.

I am just curious why you think Joe would do it?

JRE is great exposure for Ants show. He would never shit on his brother, as that would be shitting on his own dinner plate too.

Brother Joe is a douche but he has no motive to do so.

I mean if you want to trash Bother (intentional typo) Joe, just do it, we will pile on, no need for a conspiracy theory dude.

I was really disappointed with Ant's appearance on JRE. They didn't really dive too deeply into anything, and Anthony had his "completely agreeable guy" persona up the whole time, so it was a lot of Rogan going over the same talking points he has hundreds of times.

I noticed that too, but I think Joe wanted to get Ants story out there, as he admires Anthony very much, and does not want him branded with the "scarlett letter "R" "

Joe kept leading him back to the subject over the course of the show.

I see what you mean. The episode was good damage control if nothing else.

But it makes me wonder... so much of Anthony's best material on O&A was him getting annoyed and ornery. How much of that is going to happen when he's doing his own show and calls all the shots?

Once again, /r/opieandanthony speculation turns out to be wrong.

It was youtube's automatic ContentID system

Fuck this guy and his crappy one min video.

It's pretty cringy if you ask me

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=01zXo6g7l-o

jim finds himself in that position pretty frequently. lol