My thoughts on the Anthony Cumia Show.

9  2014-08-07 by [deleted]

I'm enjoying it a lot more than I thought it would. A few thoughts:

  1. He needs someone to be his straight man that will introduce news stories, videos, and topics. He should just do a casting call like Adam Carolla did until they find someone who is good. There's got to be a million talented people in New York who would kill to do that job for little to no pay.

  2. I enjoy the show more when I listen to it purely as audio. The visual element tends to be very awkward and uncomfortable. If they're going to do a visual element, Anthony needs to quit acknowledging the audience so much and make it feel like people just hanging out... that's the charm of the O&A style.

  3. I think it'd be cool if he brought some sort of overarching order and plan to the show. For instance, Mondays would be 1-on-1 interviews, Fridays would be by the pool, Tuesdays would be news and videos, etc.

  4. There's some tech and volume issues that need to be resolved. No big deal for now.

66 comments

ie. he needs an Opie...

[deleted]

Fawkin touchdown cocksucka! Tss Tss

He needs an ideological balance. A smart person who is not condescending who respects Ants views, agrees with some but can slam him down for certain things.

Speaking of which, are there any podcasts hosted by people who are extremely different politically?

OK, OK, OK, I'll be his co-host. Next time just ask instead of beating around the bush.

Yeah, I really enjoyed yesterday's show but after a while it became a bit like a right wing propaganda presentation. His politics/racial opinions were fine on O&A because other people wouldn't let him get away with outrageous statements, but now it's just an echo chamber.

I wouldn't call that a "need." Most people aren't unhealthily obsessed with other people's ideologies and don't let politics dominate whether or not they enjoy something.

Or someone that no one likes who is paid to represent the opposite side, like what Colmes did for Hannity.

I said not condescending.

...aaaand suddenly I miss Patrice again!

I've been thinking about him more since Ant got fired. Especially because of the circumstances of his firing. Fuck. I really wish he took better care of himself.

I can't believe we got down votes for missing Patrice.

I had "Mr. P" on the other day and I was remembering how cool he was to me as a comedian and the amount of advice he gave me about the business. Yeah, he didn't take any shit from anyone in the business, but he knew how to pay the game, he just did it his way.

Stuntbrain would be good... He's pretty smart TSS.. But yeah he can be alright

Personally I absolutely love the visual element. I love seeing Ant's reaction to things after years of only hearing it. It might just be the novelty of it because it's new, but I always loved seeing video clips of stuff that happened on the show and the video element of the first O&J show too.

EDIT: Plus, without the visual element, I wouldn't have been able to laugh my ass off at what was possibly the most poorly made captain and coke in human history.

Watching that girl get increasingly bored as she stood there for 2 hours was the best part of that show.

I agree on all points. I don't really like looking at Anthony as he is distractingly ghoulish to watch.

Maybe he can do the whole thing himself. The first two shows have been funny so far.

He could, but it will be a far better show if he has someone else in the studio

I've been happy with it so far. I would like to see some more "friends of the show" comedians come on as guests. Maybe Ant hasn't asked them yet while he gets used to doing the show. I know he won't get somebody like Louie but Vos and Bobby shouldn't have a problem being a guest.

I think that it is finding its shoes. It flows alot better than the Opie and Jimmy show has been. I hope they get back together in oct. and rebuild their brand, otherwise Im Anthony Cumia Show all the way.

My opinion is that it's a somewhat sober at a decent hour Live From The Compound.

yeah... somewhat.

Is there going to be a free outlet for the audio only, or does it cost money?

[deleted]

Yeah, it does feel a tad uncomfortable to watch when Ant makes goofy faces and awkward flailing arm movements while doing his otherwise hilarious voices.

Does he still look above the camera? I've only seen the first epsiodes and found it really distracting. Looked like he needed an Interrotron setup where images are projected onto a TelePrompTer screen.

Ha. He needs interns

I personally don't actually watch Anthony at all, because I've not lost a war or done anything wrong enough to deserve that.

I also don't give a crap about the video as far as day to day viewership goes. Although it will absolutely be great to look back upon crazy shit when it happens, and it will, so I am glad he's doing it even if it doesn't generally interest me.

I like the show a lot more when he's with a guest. He should also go to a "Larry King Style" table when he has guests on. The Dice interview worked when they were both at the table, but having that reporter on and both looking at the camera instead of each other didn't.

It sucks dick

I agree I think he should do a casting call unless you're doing sports or political talk its hard to do a show by yourself he needs someone to set him up like Pepper Hicks sets up Ron Bennington but overall I think the show is great and I'm excited to see more.

Punctuation is your friend.

Haha yeah i suck at that.

If there were baseball cards but for radio, Anthony's solo hosting stat would be 3/10.

It's like he needs someone funny to play off of and another guy who knows how to do technically good radio.

I think the show should be 3 hours long.

He could have two 5 min commercial breaks.

He definitely needs a side kick. I specifically didn't say co-host, because he doesn't need someone to share 50% of the show with. He just needs someone to bounce things off and fill in gaps and change atmosphere. Nick Diapolo as the straight man sidekick would be great.

They are similar politically, but Dipaolo seems less controversial. For example they were talking about Niggermania.com on O&A a few months ago and Anthony said he loves sites like that, and he finds them funny. Dipaolo said he doesn't like sites like that. Dipaolo is also an expereinced radio host so he would be great as a side kick. He's also one of the best comedians and would help keep things funny and light.

Anthony is hilarious, but also has rants where there is little to no humor. Dipaolo would add to those rants a lot. Their banter is amazing too.

Anthony doesn't have to pay a co-host 50%, why would he do that unless that co-host would bring in more subscriptions(like possibly Opie & Jim would).

Personally if Opie and Jimmy continue on SiriusXM I'd like to see Sean Bergin and Scorch join up with Anthony.

I meant 50% of the time on the air.

Ah, no matter who he gets(outside of Opie), he'll be in charge.

You're dreaming. Nick Diapolo is a long shot. He's too established to spend the time on something like The Anthony Cumia Show.

Nick Dipaolo as co-host would be awesome he's hilarious but unfortunately i doubt he'd do that.

This is a serious question: Is there anything Ant will do that you people wont like? I love O&A and I have for some time, but so far Ant's show has been anything but stellar. I watched the first live and learned that I can't watch his show live because there are stretches of boredom I can't deal with. Then, I watched the replay of the dice show. There were so many cringe moments I almost had to shut it off. I admit the girl behind the bar was worth the air time. All he did was do Dice impressions, to Dice.... if I were Dice I'd tell him to stop fucking impersonating myself to me. And then he had Dice's weird uncomfortable kids just sit there and look stupid. And then, once he was good and liquored up, he jumped in the pool and yelled some more. Is this really quality entertainment to you guys? I'm seriously questioning what you guys do other than fuck stuffed animals through the crotch hole in your filthy depends and drool to anything Anthony or Jim does... oh and curse Opie, can't forget that.

"The girl behind the counter was worth the air time." - Why even add that in? Anyone can watch pornography at any moment. No one is tuning into a podcast to see a clothed girl stand behind a bar 20 feet away. If anything, the whole "token female" gimmick is corny.

Watching the girl behind the bar awkwardly get more bored as the show progressed was the best part of the show.

jesus asshole i was trying to throw a positive swing into my diarrhea.

Dude we are on day 3. It's going to be a little rocky until he finds his way. I would wait 3 weeks before you let the pessimism sit in.

no no, I did not say I wasn't optimistic nor hopeful of Ant getting his groove and making a good show. No, I have heard some of the funniest radio moments of my life from O&A. What is fucking retarded is this unconditional love for Ant and Jim. You think Ant can compete with the show as it is right now? If you read this sub, then you'd think, oh fuck yeah, he's gonna be a superstar. His show as of right now is going to die fast unless it changes. And if all his fucking fan boys tell him it's gold then why would he change it?

Just cancel your sub Danny, nobody cares that you don't like it

And if all his fucking fan boys tell him it's gold then why would he change it?

I guarantee he has as many, if not more, telling him how much he sucks.

Why does it bother you if people enjoy Anthony's show and you don't? Is being part of the flock-mentality that important to you?

Huh, that's a very interesting conclusion. What sample population are you basing that very interesting conclusion on? I'm basing mine on tweets to him, phone calls, and the posts to this subreddit. However, you must be privy to a completely different population than I've seen. Please, tell me how you drew that conclusion. I would change my conclusion immediately. Thank you for your service good sir, you are fighting the good fight.

Damn I was looking at your post history and you got real anger issues and explode at all kinds of dumb shit. Get help.

anger issues aren't even the half of it. there is no help for some people.

[deleted]

I totally agree , this isnt quality entertainment i especially question the people that sit at home in from of their tv and computers and watch it, if you listen to it in your car i get that (although its a huge hassle) but to sit and watch this drivel when we are in a golden age of television and there is a million good shows to watch is mind boggling.

I hope he figures it out, he needs to treat it more like a radio show to be honest and start explaining visual elements so that people can treat it as such. Ant is not a visual talent hes an audio talent.

Tss... tell us how u really FEEL

Boom! Home run! Moded, corroded, his booty exploded!

I still haven't seen/heard it. I want to check it out before I think about subscribing. Cuz like you sorta mentioned. I don't expect to dig it that much, at least not even close enough to wanna pay for it

first show sucked ass but 2nd show was pretty decent and he asked Dice real interesting questions even though it was by the pool Ant did conduct a real interview.

Yesterday was a cool new thing Ant did conducting a pool side interview and today (I am listening now) is the closest we have got back to the old O&A show.

What you mean? When did the old O&A show ever do anything like conducting an interview pool side? Hate to tell you (cuz you clearly sound like a Opie hater, or at least Antohny fanboy). The O&J show has been pretty damn solid. I've thoroughly enjoyed almost every episode. And the guys have been on top of their shit and making sure they have a third and even fourth mic for every single show since they came back. I still love the show. The only thing that sucks is how often I think to myself "Oh man I wish Ant was here right now" Even though I really enjoy having Florentine on (even more then Soder) and he's been the most frequent third mic so far

Did you miss the part where I said cool NEW thing? Emphasis on NEW.

Also O&J has been shit except for when Jimmie's friends come on then it's been good. Without the comedians there to do the heavy lifting the show is shit. Will they keep coming on? If so, ok the show has a shot and I will occasionally keep listening. If not the show is finished, kaput.

They have had someone come on every single day. Solder, florentine, Vos, Bennington, bobby Kelly, Chris distefano, slayton, even Todd Barry made his debut today. Some of those guys I like much better than others, but my point is they have and will indeed keep bringing guys in. So with that said, the show has been fine. Still highly entertaining. Haven't heard ants show yet but there's no way that 2014 racist, political ant by himself (with his boring brother and crew of glad handing leeches) can compare. And this is coming from someone who fully appreciates and understands the genius of Anthony.

Can't compare? Ant's past two shows have been better than the O&J show those days.

No

hat 2014 racist, political ant by himself

What a shock another liberal who hates Ant.

The buccaneer port. If you catch my drift.

The ol' somalian harbour, if you smell what I'm stepping in.

Avast! Ya scurvy skinny.

The $7 bucks for a single month going to break your bank?

Judging by his hatred of Ant's politics I'm going to assume he doesn't have a bank account.

Did you miss the part where I said cool NEW thing? Emphasis on NEW.

Also O&J has been shit except for when Jimmie's friends come on then it's been good. Without the comedians there to do the heavy lifting the show is shit. Will they keep coming on? If so, ok the show has a shot and I will occasionally keep listening. If not the show is finished, kaput.

I've been thinking about him more since Ant got fired. Especially because of the circumstances of his firing. Fuck. I really wish he took better care of himself.