This centers around the SelfCuttingGirl catfish story, in which a 40 year old man fooled Anthony, and many others, into believing he was a 14 year old girl. Read that post here. Also, keep in mind that this is who these people thought they were communicating with.

EDIT: They deleted the Instagram pic of DJ Whoo Kid, Hembrough, and E-Rock! Here it is.

"The Hunter" is Jordan Hembrough and the other girl-friend mentioned is shelbys__tweets; who claims to have turned 18 in late 2016, which would have made her around 13 or 14 when all of this was going down. I find it hard to believe that this is a real person, but that doesn't matter. It's worth mentioning that this is one of the "real girls" Anthony brings up when discussing the reveal on the show. Anthony still follows this girl on twitter, btw, or at least he did before he was banned.

We'll start at the end and then [double back] (http://imgur.com/a/zYz4L) to when Jordan Hembrough, a TV show host in his 40's, decided it was appropriate to contact what he believed to be a 14 year old girl, make inappropriate comments, take her on as a pseudo employee, and make even more inappropriate jokes that would make even Chip cringe (It's like an Army joke). Oof. You probably noticed a reference to Penn Jilette in there, too. Apart from Anthony and Jordan, Penn was one of the most publicly engaging celebrities.

Now here's the old O&A gang discussing the fact that they'd been had. The more I listen to this the more I notice how panicked everyone sounds. High-pitch Jimmy denies knowing anything about her while also claiming that he knew she was really a he all along, Opie kinda knows something, but not as much as everyone else, and Anthony tries to frame the conversation in a way that emphasizes how much of a creep this guy is for pretending to be an underage girl, despite the fact that he had been grooming "her" for well over a year.

Yeah, about that: Here's an old thread full of information. Linked threads: first and second. Here's Anthony denying that he'd ever been catfished in the first place & the thread. Remember ApologyGirl21? This is her. It's possible that this girl is one of the "real friends" that Ant was complaining about opening up to SelfCuttingGirl, too. Here's the thread where Ant deletes his denial. Here's Anthony claiming that he bought SelfCuttingGirl a macbook because he's a charitable fellow. Here's Ant's 17 year old girlfriend, ApologyGirl21, being used to lure in more strays and Ant offering SelfCuttingGirl room and board.

Here's a section of a blog post by Melissa Statten, one of Anthony's ex's, entitled: Trophy Wife aka My Life With A Shock Jock & the full version, which discusses her finding out that he had saved this 14 year old girl's Amazon wishlist "because she's a fan of the show and she's cute". Here's Anthony publicly thumbing his nose at his ex for getting upset that he's purchasing gifts for what he believed to be a 14 year old girl. Here's a bonus clip of Melissa Statten exposing Tranthony Cumio as a ladyboy lover and the thread. I should probably clarify why the Sue Lightning/tranny stuff is relevant...This is why.

The reason I haven't posted any direct communications between Anthony and this "girl" is because at some point during the whole hullabaloo of Ant admitting that he was catfished, then claiming that the catfished story never happened, him saying she was just a girl who the guys on the show retweeted, then claiming that he bought her things because he's a charitable guy, and even going so far as to pretend that SelfCuttingGirl was his niece at one point...he decided to wipe his entire twitter account the same way he wiped his Vine account. Bonus: His reaction to the Vine likes. The only problem with wiping your account clean is that all of the @ mentions are still there. There are some speculative things. I'm not sure what to make of that. I don't know who that message was sent to, but there's enough left over to paint a picture of what was really going on. Plus, you'd be a fool to not take the man at his word.

A few more instances:

• Anthony brings suspected child porn to play on the show.
• Anthony creeps out some teenage girls by taking pictures of them in a restaurant. Archived photo and Tweets.
• Here he is taking a creepshot of a girl who couldn't have been more than 8 years old.
• Another round of 'How young would you go' where Anthony "jokes" about having sex with 9 year olds. He later changes his answer to 15.
• There's his friendship with Kurt Love, the sex offender who was sent to prison for sodomizing a 12 year old.
• Here's Anthony drooling over Bobo's underage sister and a thread where former producer for O&A, Danny (/u/TheBlueAwning), claims that convicted pedophile, Kurt Love aka Jeffery Hollander, brought Bobo's then 16 year old sister and a friend over to Anthony's house for a pool party. Link and archive link of the thread where he delivers with the photo that corroborates his story. Here's Anthony's response to Danny (1hr35mins) and Danny's response to the response, in which Danny alleges that Anthony digitally penetrated a 14 year old girl in his home theater room. Archive link.
• Anthony drooling over the 13 year old cash me outside girl. Taken from TACS 537 1:12:00. He filed a copyright claim on the latter for obvious reasons, but the thread is still up. Edit: A little snippet of the kinds of things he was saying and a follow up clip.
• In 2006 Ant did an impression of a guy defending his own pedophilia. He later went on to repeat those words, but in defense of himself.
• He referred to Roman Polanski as a hero for anally raping a 13 year old girl.
• E-Rock and Opie lied to Olympic gymnast Mikayla Mirony, then 17, for a disturbing bit on the show. What makes this even more egregious on their part is that it took place after Anthony had caused a Twitter shit storm by Tweeting about breaking Mikayla's hymen. Some of the Tweets, which were all sent before this bit, are saved in this article.
• On August 14, 2018 it was discovered that former O&A producer, Erik Nagel, made a comment in a thread titled "What should have stayed in Vegas, but didn't?" on /r/AskReddit about a former co-worker. He wrote, "An ex co-worker of mine got blackout drunk and wouldn't stop trying to pick up this young teen in front of her family. Her father almost fought him, but an off-duty police officer stepped in and convinced the guy to get upstairs and go to bed." Within a couple of hours of this admission being posted to /r/opieandanthony Erik wiped his account history and created two new posts in an attempt to make it look like the account was owned by someone else. There have been rumors circulating that Erik would be joining Anthony's podcast network in some capacity prior to this happening, which would explain his panic.
• This is a Periscope video taken by his ex, Dani Brand (Golightly), in which she says that the only reason Anthony bought a drone was to look at middle school girls. In the video he can be seen hovering the drone over the local middle school and junior high school.
• Here's Anthony saying that he would only watch ICarly to jerk off. Jimmy seriously asks what's wrong with him. There's no joke there.
• Here's an original Brother Joe song about the Olson Twins and a bit about them from the show called "Ant's in my Pants". It goes without saying, but both were recorded prior to their 18th birthdays.
• Another instance of him commenting on how hot he finds a teenage girl.
• In this clip Anthony insinuates that if he had become a carnival worker he would have statutory rape charges all across America for sleeping with 14 year olds.
• There's the whole 'Ant goes to prom' bit, too. Part 1 and Part 2.
• Here's a clip of him saying that a 14 year old prostitute on Maury is "completely, legitimately fuckable".
• Bill Burr says that Anthony has The Neverland Ranch for someone who doesn't molest kids and Anthony replies with, "...Little do you know."
• Here he is admitting to finding the sexual abuse of women arousing. Here he is taking photos of a passed out girl and posting them to Twitter.
• Here he is flat out admitting that he slept with a 14 year old when he was 21...or 18? Either way, it's illegal.
• This is possibly a reference to the same girl. This time he says that he was dating a 15 year old when he was 19 years old.

SelfCuttingGirl's ask.fm page. The questions are anonymous, obviously, but I feel this also helps to paint a fuller picture of the relationship between Cumia and what he thought was a 14 year old girl.

• Addressing the old ParamoreCunt handle
• The hate for Danny Ross
• How she got into O&A
• Are you trying to get Cumia to bed you
• Why does @MelissaStetten hates you
• Someone asks about her underwear and then follows up with a "I'm turned on, haha", which makes me think it was Cumia.
• Sex with older guys
• Do you like hot tubs and guns? Anthony stop asking me;)
• Do you masturbate to people from Twitter
• Has Ant ever touched you
• Romantic with Cumia, that didn't answer the question, and how old she was when she first started talking to Cumia
• Wanna shoot a .50 cal, toots? or have you
• iPhone 6 for sex and the sugar daddy
• Ever met Ant in person?
• A suggestive picture request and the famous wishlist

​

04/20/19 UPDATES from original post (made by a user who since has deleted their account) by u/bovinebrain:

• Anthony gets horned up over a 13-14 year old Bindi Irwin, daughter of the deceased Steve Irwin.
• Anthony tweets out pictures of a pool party where things eventually turn sinister with what appears to be a passed out girl in his home theater. my yard looks like The Nam!, 1st shot of girls 2nd shot of girls, 3rd shot of girls, 4th shot of girls, Well, I'm gonna to need a PH test in this thing thing., Darn this steamy pool. Can't get a good pic., I love the "Pull yourself up the waterfall" game., I just see arms, legs, ass and tits., 1st shot inside Ant's house, 2nd shot inside Ant's house, 1st shot inside home theater, 3rd shot inside Ant's house, 2nd shot inside home theaterThat girl's name apparently is Elizabeth and was a friend of Anthony's former girlfriend Melissa Stetten according to this video from Stetten's YouTube.
• Anthony holds a creepy high school graduation party for his 17-year old girlfriend. No more high school, Well deserved pool party, By the time you see it, it's too late
• A severely drunk Anthony describes and shows off his lust for the young on livestream to the discomfort of everyone.
• Anthony calls a little girl a bitch for refusing to interact with him during his livestream.
• Anthony jokes about the possibility he could be convicted of rape during his livestream.
• Anthony brings Vinnie, an FBI agent he identifies as his friend, onto his livestream. He talks about he gives Vinnie complete access to his pool and home even when Ant isn't home. Then he brings up that Vinnie can watch him anytime from a webcam in Ant's home and that if he was doing anything wrong that would concern him but he's not doing anything wrong. As proven by the FBI agent "friend" he keeps close to him who he, at the very least, regularly gives special privileges to his home.
• Some potentially questionable pictures Anthony has tweeted that haven't been addressed elsewhere in this post. High stakes game. All in, 2 babies., O&A producer Travis Tefft brings his child to Ant's pool, Anthony with unidentified blood on a rag, Anthony (alone?) with his niece, Anthony (alone again?) with his niece, Anthony with Ex-Girlfriend Jill Nicolini's baby niece, Anthony with Ex-Girlfriend Jill Nicolini's child nieces, Anthony assisting Ex-Girlfriend Jill Nicolini's child niece
• Anthony's brother, Joseph Cumia, did a Reddit AMA where he would go on to delete all his answers for some reason. In that AMA he attempted to deflect questioning about his brother's alleged pedophilia before admitting that his brother was a child groomer. Joe would later dismiss suggestions Anthony was attempting to groom his niece using the same iPad bait he's been alleged to use on other kids with the strong defense that "I really know my brother". And as we all know, you should always take Anthony and Joe at their word.